Enhancing Broker Transparency in Freight Transactions

The trucking industry is an essential component of the American economy, and small-business truckers play a vital role in keeping goods moving across the nation. However, concerns have been raised regarding the lack of transparency in freight transactions involving brokers. In response to these concerns, two prominent organizations, the Owner Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA) and the Small Business in Trucking Coalition (SBTC), have petitioned the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) to introduce regulations that would ensure greater transparency in broker transaction records. Let's delve deeper into this issue and understand the significance of broker transparency.

The Call for Transparency

OOIDA and SBTC filed their petitions in August 2020, highlighting the need for increased oversight of broker transaction records. OOIDA's main request was to amend the regulations on broker records (49 CFR 371.3) to require brokers to provide an electronic copy of each transaction record within 48 hours of completing the contractual service. Additionally, OOIDA called for a prohibition on contract provisions that would require carriers to waive their rights to access transaction records. Similarly, SBTC requested that brokers be prohibited from coercing or requiring parties to waive their right to review transaction records as a condition for doing business.

The Importance of Transparency

Enhancing transparency in broker transactions is crucial for several reasons. Firstly, it enables motor carriers, especially small businesses, to access and review the necessary documents related to the transaction. These documents should include the amount the broker received for its service, the name of the payer, the amount of any freight charge collected by the broker, and the date it was paid to the carrier. By having access to this information, carriers can ensure they are being fairly compensated and can detect any potential discrepancies or fraudulent activities.

Moreover, broker transparency fosters a level playing field and promotes fair competition within the trucking industry. When carriers can review transaction records, they can make informed decisions about the brokers they choose to work with, based on their track record and reputation. Transparency also helps prevent brokers from engaging in unethical practices, such as colluding on prices or taking advantage of carriers' lack of information.

Regulatory Considerations and Future Developments

The FMCSA has been considering the issues raised by OOIDA and SBTC's petitions and aims to issue a decision on the matter. The agency's role is to strike a balance between statutory authorities and the resolution of identified issues through effective and efficient rulemaking. To further complicate the matter, the Transportation Intermediaries Association (TIA), which represents truck brokers, has petitioned the FMCSA to repeal the provision granting carriers the right to review broker transaction records. FMCSA is also considering TIA's as of 2024 the rules “The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) has introduced a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) titled “Transparency in Property Broker Transactions.” Published on November 20, 2024, the rule aims to address what FMCSA describes as “information gaps” and “power imbalances” in brokered transportation agreements. However, the proposed changes have sparked significant debate within the industry, raising questions about their necessity, effectiveness, and impact on stakeholders.” https://www.gcca.org/

The Outcome and Expectations

While accusations of wrongdoing and collusion among brokers have subsided in recent years due to increased freight rates and demand for capacity, the need for broker transparency remains a concern for small-business truckers. OOIDA and SBTC have persistently pushed for greater transparency, and their efforts may soon yield results. According to the U.S. Department of Transportation's Spring 2023 Unified Regulatory Agenda, FMCSA is projected to publish a notice of proposed rulemaking on broker transparency in property carrier transactions in June 2023. However, it is essential to note that delays are common in the rulemaking process, so the exact timeline may vary.

Enhancing broker transparency

Enhancing broker transparency in freight transactions is a crucial step towards creating a fair and competitive marketplace for small-business truckers. The petitions submitted by OOIDA and SBTC have shed light on the need for clearer regulations that ensure timely access to transaction records and prevent carriers from being coerced into waiving their rights. As the FMCSA progresses towards making a decision on these petitions, the trucking industry eagerly awaits a more transparent and equitable environment. By addressing these issues, the industry can build trust and promote a healthier relationship between carriers and brokers, ultimately benefiting all stakeholders involved in the freight transportation process.

Bloom Services, Inc

Here at Bloom Services, we are 100% OTR trucking. We offer newer trucks, and cover trailer and cargo liability. We do not pay base on mileage, rather we pay 80% gross load. This is beneficial for strong drivers with a decent work ethic, you will earn based on the actual load rather than mere miles. Our drivers average $3,000 plus a week take home pay after all expenses, like fuel, truck rent, etc. If you have Grit, and the endurance to consistently deliver loads and run for at least three weeks at a time, you can take home $150K a year. If you are interested, apply now.